On screen
Cast
126 credited performers
Ryan Hansen
Ben Lewis
Danneel Ackles
Sara Maxwell
Zach Cregger
Aaron Greenway
André Holland
Julian 'Fitz' Fitzgerald
Jessica Lucas
Riley Elliott
Jennifer Chang
Ula
Ali Cobrin
Hope Prater
Abby Wathen
Clementine
Elle Young
Waitress
Patrick Heusinger
Austin
Scott Michael Foster
Daniel
Nicky Whelan
Colleen
Camille Guaty
Katie Finelli
Alexandra Holden
Dakota
Tug Coker
Rich
Michael G. Canaan
Dirty Mike
Cameron Goodman
Molly
Robert Covarrubias
Horse Trainer
Eben Ham
Golf Pro
Rachelle Wood
Ben's Date
Deborah Benson
Ben's Mom
Harmon Jones
Aaron (11 Year Old)
Nicholas Braico
Ben (11 Year Old)
Drew Turner
Aaron (15 Year Old)
Carolina Hilderbrand
Aaron's Dream Girl
Merritt Yohnka
Congressman
Bryce Hitchcock
Aaron's Dream Girl (11 Year Old)
Alexandra Ackerman
Kissing Bridesmaid #1
Matthew Broadley
Ben's Friend - Age 11
Harlan Hegna
Gym Patron
Max Napolitano
Hot Gym Couple
Asun Ortega
India
Julianna Piechoczek
Kissing Bridesmaid
Kasey Shirk
Coffee Barista
John Brotherton
Dr. Matt
Jenica Bergere
Mary Resnick
James Devoti
Paul
Joey Allen
Gym Oogler
Valerie Azlynn
Kristen
Jeremy Kent Jackson
Trey
Todd Giebenhain
Dave
Anneliese Van Der Pol
Beth
Jessica Kessler
Party Friend
Collette Wolfe
Megan Harriman
Tina Lifford
Marsha
Mikey Day
Derek
Dave Foley
Keith
Travis Schuldt
Steve
Phillip J. Cates
Young Fitz
Tonya Kay
Burlesque Dancer
Ryan McPartlin
Evan Macklam
Sara Fletcher
Mia
Frank Novak
Detective
Shaan Sharma
Passerby
Anne Faulkner
Old Woman
Paul Diaz
Bartender
Bryan Krasner
Depressed Fan
Daryl Crittenden
Mugger
Sandra Luesse
Officer Trish
Merry Simkins
Mia's Mom
Craig Stepp
Mia's Dad
Elliot Goldwag
Mia's Grandfather
Franklin Ruehl
Basketball Game Attendee
Kevin Christy
Kyle
Jillian Bell
Amanda
Blake Lee
Dean
Sunkrish Bala
Wes
Jessica Blair Herman
Lauren
Jonathan Nail
Auctioneer
Troy Bishop
Bartender
Randa Walker
Hot Woman
Ashley Daniels
Girl Who Kisses Dean
Lee Garlington
Billie
Brent Briscoe
Vernon
Johanna Braddy
Grace
Ross Philips
John John
Amber Stevens West
Caroline
Tara Holt
Flashing Girl
Rodney J. Hobbs
Office Haggar
Brian McNamara
Dr. Everett Lonsdale
Arielle Vandenberg
Lana
Kaylee DeFer
Mary Webber
Jack David Frank
Young Aaron
Cassidy Ann Shaffer
Young Mary
Lenny Citrano
Phillip
Keith Chandler
Dentist
Shirley Jordan
Nurse
Seth Duhame
Noah
Heather Pugh
Birth Mother
Kyle Davis
Blind Todd
Paula Marshall
Claire Prater
Brooklyn Sudano
Kat
Christina Pickles
Hazel
Jack Guzman
Construction Worker
Tony Donno
Reporter
Pete Wentz
Joe
Rebecca Mader
Ariel
Carrie Wiita
Emma
Roshan Cook
Girl #1
Phillip Jeanmarie
Scene Guy
Chelsea Gilligan
Scene Girl
Sarah Buehler
Nerdy Test Taker
Pilar Holland
Proctor
Katie Wallack
Angry Test Taker
Sheldon Coolman
Angry Test Taker #2
Jeff Meacham
Dennis
Naomi Peters
Woman
Lindsay Davis
Adriana Lima / Belle Model Waitress
David MacAulay
Hot Dog Customer
Shantel Wislawski
Corinne
Deb Hiett
Female Interviewer
Eric Davis
Police Officer
Matthew McKelligon
Gay Couple Boyfriend
Camilla Luddington
Woman
Erica Piccininni
Lucy
Lauriane Gilliéron
Cecile
Emily Happe
Rebecca
Jordan Dunn
Amish Man
Danny Wynands
Amish Saw Guy #1
Jim Sharp
Amish Saw Guy #2
Oakley Lehman
Amish 2x4 Guy #1
Scott Workman
Amish 2x4 Guy #2
Stephanie Haney
French Tourist
Chris Prascus
Helmut
Owen Williams
Guy
Jenna Finley Moller
Girl