On screen
Cast
64 credited performers
Tim Robinson
Various Characters
Sam Richardson
Character not listed
Patti Harrison
Candy
Conner O'Malley
Marcus / Rick
Tim Heidecker
Gary
Brandon Wardell
Character not listed
Will Forte
Character not listed
Artie O'Daly
Alan
Jessica Parker Kennedy
Megan
Zach Kanin
Character not listed
Andy Samberg
Paul
Jessica Jade Andres
Melissa
Matt Knudsen
John
Fred Willard
New Joe
Cecily Strong
Brenda
Dayna Dooley
Colleen
Lauran September
Dawn
Carmella Riley
Nancy
Whitmer Thomas
Character not listed
Sisa Grey
Character not listed
Eugene Kim
Character not listed
JR Reed
Character not listed
Shelli Boone
Character not listed
Gary Richardson
Character not listed
Brooks Wheelan
Lead Singer
Alex Aiono
Character not listed
Marcos De Silvas
Character not listed
Iker Paramo
Character not listed
Joyce Greenleaf
Character not listed
Amanda Reed
Character not listed
Gregory A. Thompson
Character not listed
Harry Zinn
Character not listed
Bunny Gibson
Character not listed
Ellie Reed
Lauren
Bob Odenkirk
Man in Diner
Ruben Rabasa
Focus Group Man #1
Steven Yeun
Jacob
Vanessa Bayer
Brenda
Curtis Webster
Dr. Skull
Shawntay Dalon
Character not listed
Rhys Coiro
Billy
Bob McDuff Wilson
Professor Uribe
Biff Wiff
Detective Crashmore
John Early
Leslie
Tracey Birdsall
Janeane
Julia Butters
Toby
Ryan Caldwell
Jack
Rob Raco
Brandon
Ashley Boettcher
Claire
Fred Armisen
Character not listed
Ayo Edebiri
VR Shopping Spree Host
Rico E. Anderson
Character not listed
Mitra Jouhari
Meredith
Beck Bennett
Stuart
Tim Meadows
Father of the Bride
Jason Schwartzman
Character not listed
Alberto Isaac
Don Bondarley
Niles Abston
Character not listed
Julia Nolan
Waiter
Judy Kain
Dog Owner
Chris Prinzo
Ray (Dangerous Night Crew)
Chelsey Donn
Jill
Eric Rahill
Character not listed
Alexandra Ornelas
Character not listed