On screen
Cast
141 credited performers
Josh Groban
Tony Caruso Jr.
Tony Danza
Tony Caruso Sr.
Monica Barbaro
Cora Vasquez
Isiah Whitlock Jr.
Burl Loomis
Bill Kottkamp
Ryan Domki
Brooke Carrell
Detective
John Scurti
Wendell Kirk
Victor Cruz
Sergeant Rudner
Matthew Saldivar
Gordy
Glenn Fitzgerald
Father Kokesh
Frank Whaley
Joseph Privett
Alice Spivak
Mrs. Spiro
Molly Price
Captain
Ann Mahoney
Phyllis
Adam DeCarlo
CSI Tech
Stacey Raymond
Another Uniform Cop
Rebecca Rittenhouse
Macy Clark
Connor Tillman
Deputy Tillman
Emma Ishta
Belinda Mannix
Christopher James Baker
Corey Speck
Teddy Coluca
Al Monte
Andrew Dolan
Lionel Sykes
Alanna Ubach
Debbi Paddock
Joe Holt
Agent Conway
Aaron Serotsky
Agent Hodges
Chaka DeSilva
Remy DeRosa
Bob Saget
Richie Knight
Andy Grotelueschen
Dr. Alvin Roundie
Billy Malone
Sergeant Chet Finch
Orfeh
Donna Livingston
John Carroll Lynch
Sherman Smalls
David Furr
Mickey
Margo Seibert
Lois Ronstadt
C. Thomas Howell
Businessman
Joy Suprano
Jocelyn
Brooke Langton
Joy
Edward Carnevale
Dorfirio Santini
Dan Byrd
Donovan Demark
Caroline Aaron
Olivia Nyborg
Alyssa Cheatham
Young girl
Lynn Marocola
NYPD (uncredited)
Alexander Flores
Stork
Alex Webb
Inspector Quinn
Mattea Conforti
Young Niece
Sedly Bloomfield
Landlord
Agnes Chung
News Reporter
Max Daniels
Jack Livingston
Diane Findlay
Friendly Aunt
Ron Scott
Police Union Rep
Scott Aiello
Sgt. Aiello
Greg Crowe
Barbershop Customer
Stan Demidoff
Sgt. Stanley
Ambrose Martos
Curious Hal
Dave Mizzoni
Second Fan
Jun Naito
Forensic Investigator
Ariel Padilla
Big Fan
Ellen Ratner
Mrs. Zucker
Gurdeep Singh
Mr. Patel
Steven Solis
Frankie Storch
Justin Ahdoot
College Student
Jason Michael Evans
Masked CSI Officer
Gina Ferrall
Quinlan's Secretary
Fred Inkley
Sgt. Wickes
Jamil A.C. Mangan
State Trooper
Christopher Mann
Prison Warden
Alex Orthwein
Guy at Ringside
Hannah D. Scott
Brooke Smalls
Hannah Tinker
Helen Quinlan
Allan R. Walker
Referee
Andre B. Blake
Dr. Kornbluth
Steve Cirbus
Nolan Zander
Reade Kelly
Joey Wingate
Eden Malyn
Cynthia
Harry Sutton Jr.
Dale Coruthers
O'Neil Thomas
Shoe Rental Guy
Bill Timoney
Alley Manager
Cory Candrilli
Coranet Reality Bowler
Melissa O'Donnell
Joey's Niece
Jose Guns Alves
Enforcer
Carly Brooke
Jolene
Chris Doi
First Paramedic
Gavin Haag
FBI Special Agent #2
Jo D. Jonz
FBI Special Agent #1
Thomas Kopache
Mr. Entwhistle
Larissa Laurel
Second Paramedic
Geraldine Leer
DeRosa's Lawyer
Michael Nostrand
Laundromat Manager
Marcos Palma
Roach
Shaun Rey
Enrico Kraus
Leila Sbitani
Local Reporter
Anthony Vincent
Street Musician
Tony White
Bartender
Michael-Scott Druckenmiller
FDNY Paramedic
Hugo Salazar Jr.
Agent Rhinehart
Joseph Dellger
Studio Official
Alix Elias
Mrs. Prima
Jacqueline Guillen
First Volunteer
Mary Neely
Backstage PA
Terrence Shingler
Studio Guard
Kensington Tallman
Amateur Magician
Tam Young
Second Volunteer
Quentin
Loud audience member
Kate Grimes
Karen Trumbo
Andy Taylor
Sheriff Gaddy
Brennan Taylor
Andre Rifkin
Bryan Burton
Frank Malton the Desk Clerk
Donald Flores
Maintenance Worker
Aaron David Kapner
Friendly Cop
Maximillian McNamara
Daryl Teasdale
Dean Neistat
Skier
Angel Pai
Attractive Woman
Claire Saunders
Macy's Desk Clerk
Pablo Thomas
Ski Instructor
Ashlyn Alessi
Lodge Staff
Domenico Del Giacco
Harry
Josh Segarra
Warren
Stephanie Kurtzuba
Evelyn
Clyde Baldo
Stax
Jeffrey Bean
City Clerk
John Goodlow
Officiant
Christopher Joseph Gray
Patrol Officer
Charmar Jeter
Bar Patron
Ricardo Cortés
Young Busboy
Leila Grace
Adorable Girl
Tristan Griffin
Uniform Cop
Carlos Ibarra
Porfirio Santini (Busboy)
Marty Krzywonos
Frankie the Risotto Lover
Todd Lewis
First Financier
Mike Massimino
Johnny
Ava Lee Scott
Woman with Necklace
Jacqueline Springfield
Nurse
Kazy Tauginas
First Gangster
Damir Mrkulic
N.Y.P.D / Swat
David Negri
Paulie's Friend
Thaddeus Daniels
Henry the Doorman
Bonnie Flannery
Neighbor in Window
Wai Ching Ho
Dr. Kim
Lane Napper
Uniform Cop
Barbara Singer
Mrs. Ackroyd
Carol To
Vera
Danielle Farrier
Donovan's Mother