On screen
Cast
38 credited performers
Patrick Gallagher
Himself - Narrator
Lance Coughlin
NYPD Officer
Liam Higgins
Lawyer / Kansas City Cop
Benjamin Oduro
Uniform Officer #1
Elle Gabriel
Cheerleader friend
Loydeen Pulsifer
Lanie Jacobs
Avery Mull
Claudia Pikul
Artwork unavailable
Bill Hoffmann
Himself
Becky Boggs
Robyn Arnold
Aaron Dalla Villa
Bobby Ferrara
Anna Andersen
Patricia Pomeroy
Bradley Bemboom
Bobby Joe Fabian
Artwork unavailable
Tom Westfall
Himself
Artwork unavailable
Nori J. Muster
Self
Artwork unavailable
Henry Doktorski
Self
Artwork unavailable
Gaura Rader
Self
Artwork unavailable
Jacob Young
Self
Alexander Reed
Gary Santisario
Artwork unavailable
Moise Ntekereze
Joey Bennett (as Moses Ntekereze)
John Matton
Kurt Rouse
Artwork unavailable
Nataša Babić
Betty Gore
Artwork unavailable
Caroline Mae McKeon
Helen Mintiks
Artwork unavailable
Quinn Wood
Sarah Rairdon
Samantha Rivers Cole
Candy Montgomery
Artwork unavailable
Connor Moeller
Kirk Buckner
Kobi Frumer
Timothy Buckner
Byron Clohessy
Police Officer
Robert House
Detective Miller Thomas
Artwork unavailable
Nate Washburn
Sheriff Rainey
Allen Enlow
Character not listed
Gilbrando Acevedo
Deputy #2
Steve Boghossian
Steve Buckner
Artwork unavailable
Trevor Crane
Don Pierce
Matthew Wise
NYPD Officer
Artwork unavailable
William W. Wallace
Matthew Stuart (as William Wallace)
Artwork unavailable
Smith Daniels
Robert Chambers (as Daniel Patrick Smith)
Artwork unavailable
Veronica James
Diane Weaver
Justin Andrew Davis
Allan Gore