On screen
Cast
62 credited performers
Joey Graceffa
The Savant
Rosanna Pansino
The Jet-Setter
Nikita Dragun
The Troublemaker
Alex Burris
The Novelist
Colleen Ballinger
The Disco Dancer
Matthew Patrick
The Detective
Gabbie Hanna
The Vaudevillian
Manny MUA
The Jock
Tana Mongeau
The Saloon Girl
Eva Marisol Gutowski
The Journalist
Oli White
The Big Game Hunter
Tim Chantarangsu
The Con Man
Shontae Saldana
Calliope
Andrea Russett
The Mystic
Tyler Oakley
The Thespian
Bretman Rock
The Playboy
Lele Pons
The Hustler
DeStorm Power
The Enforcer
Liza Koshy
The Explorer
Matthew Haag
The Professor
Safiya Nygaard
The Investigative Reporter
Sierra Furtado
The Heiress
Justine Ezarik
The Gambler
Glozell Green
The Jazz Singer
Teala Dunn
The Super Spy
Kii
Store Clerk
Jesse Wellens
The Outlaw
Roi Fabito
The Daredevil
Alejandra Cejudo
Killer Clown Leader
Ell
Automaton Bride (as Rachel Li)
Eva Augustina Sinotte
Cult Leader
Jean-Jacques Ntshaykolo
Minotaur
Kate Sisto
Hazmat Intruder
Andrea Brooks
The Fixer
Lauren Riihimaki
The Engineer
J.C. Caylen
The Hippie
JoJo Siwa
The Burnout
Ashton Moio
Confederate Soldier
Aylya Marzolf
Sandra
Romika Annabell
Ungodly Monster
Dan Aho
Willy
Kassandra Mahea
Dancing Maiden
Guya Frazier
Cult Dancer
Cami McCullough
Delivery Girl
Jonathan Bangs
Man in Black
Kenton McCroskey
Occultist
Mackenzie Wealot
Occultist
Roy Rogers III
Occultist
Christopher Nicosia
Occultist
Angelina Wang
Occultist
Roni Speers
Occultist
Matthew Floris
Occultist
KK CUDA
Occultist
Mina Estrada
Occultist
Jack Davis
Occultist
Sierra Williams
Cult Spirit
Dakota Whitworth
Alien Spirit
Knightly Giaimo
Christmas Tree Spirit
Samantha Castillo
VHS Store Ghost
Lex Zazzo
TV Spirit
Angeline Mirenda
Peasant Woman
Shane Dawson
The Renegade