On screen
Cast
284 credited performers
Nathan Wiley
Narrator (voice)
Cherise Silvestri
Narrator (voice)
Russell Bentley
Narrator (voice)
Gino Raimondo
Detective Ronald Flagg (uncredited)
Ann Smith
Gina Nisbit
Dawn Sadler
Shelley Riley (Christina's Aunt/Guardian)
Avery Laine
Christina 'Chrissy' Long
Randy Starr
Joe Nick (Missing Persons Investigator)
Jim Canale
Glenn Kallai
Will Conlon
Wade Ridley
David McConnell
Self - True Crime Author
Joshua Pivato
Saul Dos Reis
Bernadette Medhurst
Dianne McKnight
Heath Hudson
Anthony Pasquale
David Bacque
The Boss
Marta Legrady
Deb Bruce (David's Sister)
Val Cole
Mary Kay Beck
Antonino Pruiti
Brandon White (uncredited)
Zoe Brown
Shawna Lynch
Bryan Edwards
Detective Mark Williams
Nicole Fairbairn
Jonathan's Mother (uncredited)
Sid McMillan
Lloyd Collins Jones
Stacey Iseman
Kim Philipson
John 'JR' Ross
Detective Greg Dunn (uncredited)
Eric Kuthe
Detective Jeff Allison
Gary Shannon
Ashley Pullen
Rachel Rain Packota
Razakel
Chandler Boriska
Melanie Wells
Jason C. Paul
Sam
Raina Harten
Amanda
Victoria Yau
Carol
Alyson MacFarlane
Avery
Sammy Jo Higgins
Kayleigh
Blake Canning
Aaron
Linnea Currie-Roberts
Nichole Cable
Maarika Pinkney Freund
Kristine Wiley (Nichole's Mom)
Marcus McKinley
Kyle Dube
Todd Perry
Detective Smith
Mandi Nicholson
Harleigh Robertson
Sonya Proehl
Sarah Mason (Kyle's Girlfriend & Bryan's Ex)
Brandon Wilson
Bryan Butterfield
Staci Bouskill
Teresa McBain
Stephanie Valano
Marcy
Jeremy Durgana
Detective
Aveleigh Keller
Kacie Woody
Shawn Devlin
Rick Woody
Sidney Sholdice
Jessica Bradford
Kye Deuters
Scott
Curtis Desrosiers
Lt. Jim Barrett
Jamie Tarantini
Amanda Howard
Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi
Self - ADA, Brooklyn, NY
Suzanne Pratley
Kathleen
Brendan Nasr
Alex
Halle Tator
Samantha Chonski
Emily Frye
Ashley Reynolds
Maggie Garrison
Elizabeth Shubert
Merritt Crews
Angela Reynolds
James Coburn
Special Agent Meyer
Jay Kee
Sam Dreher
Jenna Harris
Danielle Dreher
Brian McDonald
Detective Chad McDonald
Kunta Murange
Michael Minor
Alyssa Goodridge
Jasmin Nuñez
Orville Cummings
Andres Ceballos
Celine Baumans
Melanie Nuñez
Wanda Crosta
Denise Suarez
Pamela Archer
Iris
Mason Cromwell
Det. Terence Munnelly
Gloria Allred
Self (archive footage)
Madeleine Wiedmer
Autumn Pasquale
Alexandera Yetman
Barb DeFrance (Family Friend)
Joseph JR Yeboah
Dante Robinson
Diana Goldman
Leslie Belkin
Red Carlsen
George Lamp
Paige Torch
Rachel Belkin
Drew Riedstra
Major Campbell
Veronique Auger-Drolet
Renee Blanchard
Jay Brown
Mike Lamp
Brooke Samms
Megan Meier
Cheryl Poirier
Tina Meier
Greg Zajac
Ron Meier
Kim Lores
Lori Drew
Katie Dewling
Sarah Drew
Dylan Worth
Blaine Buckles
Margaret Evraire
Jessica Sacco
Timothy Hedden
Chris
Patrick McFadden
Matthew Puccio
Adam Martignetti
Andrew Forney
John Phillips
Chris Wright
Stephen Davis
Scott Davis
Richard Crossman
Jack aka Richard Beasley
Thomas Brouwer
Brogan Rafferty
Ian Awerbuck
David Pauley
Julia Flood
Ashley Smith / Lauren Gash
Sarah Jean Hodkinson
Alisa Betts
Sarah Lynn Strange
Jeana Booth, Amanda's Mom
Jason Bigio
Officer Brandon Shrout
John Laughlin
Detective Troy Pharr
Georgia Chase
Presenter
Craig Cyr
NY Cop
Tina Sterling
Neighbor
Jessé Miceli
John Katehis
Nicole Williams
Jenn Clark (wrongly credited under Jamie Elizabeth Sampson)
Nik Rogan
Ray Holycross
Samantha Wright Lawrence
Theresa Bridegroom
Emily Martell
Mikayla, Jenn's Daughter
Allen Corbalan
Connor, Theresa's Son
Alan Belerique
Aaron Thomas, Jenn's Friend
Tracy Rowland
Michele Mulford, Neighbor
Andrew Fleming
Detective Jason Mackie
Steve Rankine
FBI Special Agent Don Kleber
Nelson Perazza
Carlos Estanquiero
Johanna Garcia
Thamiris
David C. Malcolm
Pastor (uncredited)
Olenka Dabrowski
Anastasia Solovieva King
Jean-Claude Paquet
Indle King
Spencer Gatten
Daniel Larson
Jodi Morneau (Eve Edwards)
Detective Jamison
Deidre Tylecki
Patty
Sergey Volkov
Sergei Ivanov
Brian Scott Carleton
Professor Jim Aune
Michael Chwastiak
Detective Ohana
Milo Jones
Jack Hornstein
Peter Bavis
Barry Hornstein
Dave Sokolowski
Detective Bill Law
Sandra Flores
Kathy Hornstein
Natalie Novak Remplakowski
Jamie Stice
Lawrene Denkers
Jeannie Stice
Susannah Kiernan
Kathy Coy
Paul Gagnon
Mike
Roland Greber
James
Michael Pez
Chris Coleman
Melissa Burdey
Sherri Coleman
Darius Parsons
Garrett Coleman
Carter Gillam
Gavin Coleman
Shawn J. Hamilton
Detective Justin Barlow
Craig McCarthy
Sgt. Jason Donjon
Dwayne Mailman
Detective 1
Nicolas Ballarini
Justin Bloxom
Andee Frizzell
Amy Bloxom-Fletcher
Cole Smallwood
Dustin Rosegrant
Jamie McCormick
Detective Adam Ewing
Jeremy Hull
Brian Douglas Horn
E.M. White
Sgt. Keith Banta
Bart Rochon
John Witham (Amy's Brother)
Brianna Ramagnano
Grace Dillman
Jordan Cole
Robert Best
David George
Alan Dillman
Silvi Alzetta-Reali
Trace Dillman
Crisencio Amiana
Detective Ernest Choung
Helen Piecuch
Bernice Best
Kevin Jollimore
Lee Best
Sarah Strong
Michele Reiter
Lisa Robinson
Denise Worrell
David Parisian
Ranger Danny Crawford
Neil Affleck
Lanny Bush ("Rocky Switzer")
Dwayne Bryshun
Kemper Croft
Kassandra Herzog
Angela 'Angie' Allen
Brett Hallick
Seth Allen
Lori Oskam
Colleen Allen
Kamilla Kowal
Cheyenne
Robert Blake
FBI Special Agent Jimmie Caudle Jr.
Courtney Fruck
Investigator Corporal Patti Stroud
Rick Cordeiro
Earl Delmar Pigg (uncredited)
Jennifer Budinsky
Lacey Spears
River Bowden
Garnett Spears
Graham Gauthier
Terry Spears (Lacey's Dad)
Jimmy Korderas
Detective Dan Carfi
David Restrepo
Eddie Leal
Nicholas Arancibia Strachan
Gilbert Leal
Mabelle Carvajal
Celia Leal
Jamie Lujan
Manuel Guzman
Matthew Sauvé
Deputy DA Daniel DeLimon
Werner Artinger
Investigator Tony Pelato (uncredited)
Serena Miller
Leslie Long
William Mowat
Brian Long
Aidan Dennis
Tyler Long
Kate Dennis
Courtney Long
Adam Bonney
John 'JJ' Jaworski
Christopher Potter
Officer Michael Clark
Nadia Cejic
Hope Votaw
Kanza Feris
Denise Votaw
Joseph Daly
Special Agent Keith Owens
Ali Johnson
Shayla Williams
Jesse Tyrell
William Jacobs
Kevin Rees
Detective Mitch Colbath
Ray Chaaya
Steven (credited but actually not in this episode)
Erin Tancock
Heather Jones
Liam Seamus Murphy
Chris Jones
Angela Martin
Officer Cari Cooper (Heather's Friend & Dance Teacher)
Ida Jagaric
Diane Perry (Heather's Cousin)
Angelo Giammattolo
Ed Smithson
Amelie Albert-LeBlanc
Chris' Girlfriend (uncredited)
Samantha Nemeth
Amber Thompson
Melissa Cline
Kara Thompson
David Di Francesco
Anthony Thompson
Alioune Haynes
Josh Owen
Brandon McKnight
Charles 'Chuck' Davis Jr.
Christine Tsiliverdis
Candy Williams
Steven Burley
Joe Collier / Peter Zimmer
Jackie Pluim
Irene Williams
Joanne Fox
Linda
Demetri James
Detective Thaddius Coffin
Leo Choy
Detective Pham
Dini Dimakos
Reporter
Darlene Robinson
Sheila Rae Hachmeister
James 'Chilli' Chillingworth
Detective Scott Dickey
Michael Woodley
Jason Hachmeister
John Philips
Officer Aaron Hachmeister
Pastel Supernova
Egypt Carson
Frances Townend
Rhonda Bever (Sheila's Older Sister)
George Schneider
Bill Hachmeister
Winny Clarke
Tiffany Watkins
Steven Shand
Brian Hile
Tyler Patterson
Brett Hile
Jacob Klick
David Cranford
Michael Klassen
Officer 'Josh' McDaniel
Alys Crocker
Courtney Clarke (Tiffany's Cousin)
Andriah Daley
Female Detective
René Escobar Jr.
Man at Bar
Bert Cardozo
Jason Rodriguez
Vanessa Jackson
Grace Gonzalez
Domenic Derose
Israel Nieves
Sandy Ramirez
Juan Rodriguez
Brian Williams
Randall Jean
Krista Madison
Erika Miranda
Will Strickland
Detective Brian Cross
Jackie Jay
Chelsey Perkins
Margarita Valderrama
Lorianna Parker
Bradley Hamilton
"Corey Davis"
Dylan House
Brandon Wentzell
Kim DeLonghi
Cheryl Jones (Brandon's Mom)
Rachel Delduca
"Clarissa Chistiakov"
James Dalzell
Officer Stephen Shipley
Rick Amsbury
Ray Merrill
Kirsten McMillan
Marcia Loebick (Ray's Sister)
Ruth Tinker
Regina Rachid
Bruce Turner
Bill Rauch (Ray's Friend)
Peter Mazzucco
Alex Strategos
Laura Callington
Melissa Friedrich
Rae Rondeau
Judi Frock (Alex's Friend)
Christina Garcia
Megan Exon
Jeannie di Giacomo
Nicole Eason
Colin Edwards
Calvin Eason
Linda Spence
Lynne Banks
Sheronna Osbourne
Nikki McPhatter
Ophilia Davis
LaToyah McPhatter
Taija Chung
Akila Weaver
Kheon Clarke
Teddy Manning
Gail Berry
Fran Eddings (uncredited)
Michelle D'Alessandro Hatt
Officer Smith (uncredited)
Jennifer Baker
Beverly Carter
Al Braatz
Aaron Lewis / "Steven Adams"
Blair Anderson
Carl Carter Sr.
Laura Vincent
Crystal Lowery (uncredited)
Selena Buckle
Chelsea Schobert
Don Mike
Shawn Ford Jr.
Michael Findlay
Jeff Schobert
Tara Paterson
Jessica Schobert
Tara Pryce
Shania Gray
Crystal Roberts
Sherry Gray-James
Jonathan Grandchamp
Franklin 'Wish' Davis / D
Kristen Da Silva
Detective Dena Williams
Kevin Carter
Detective Jeremy Chevallier
Chantal Kloosterman
Alicia DeBolt
Ashlie White
Tammy Conrad (Alicia's Mom)
Brandon Antonio
Ivan Ramirez
Kerrie Lamb
Detective Heather Smith
Kealan Fitzpatrick
Adam 'Rocco' Longoria
Kate Schroder
Nicole White
Paul Thompson
Jonathan Harris
Michael Reusch
Detective Jason LaLiberte
Alex Strauss
Detective John Delgado
Laura Harding
Ashley Pegram
Michelle Watson
Rama Chance
Lex Kilgour
Brandy Chance
Tomas Enrique
Edward Bonilla
Kevin Monster
Detective Sgt. Andy Martin
Melissa Taylor
Chelsea Martinez
Reece Presley
Jason Nisbit
Brian Quintero
Oscar Martinez
Wendy German
Elizabeth Smuck (Chelsea's Mom)
Brian Russell
Prosecutor Chris Berhalter
Erika Swayze
Poppy (14-16) (uncredited)