On screen
Cast
92 credited performers
D.C. Goode
Narrator (voice)
Jason Shablik
Narrator (voice)
Samuel Goergen
Logan
Christie McNab
Heather Kelso
Rolando Madigral
Gerry DeJesus
Michael Hanson
Matt Kelso
Jimmy Dempster
Hank
Nicole Lamb
Briana Helwick
Andrés Erickson
Avery
Kate Dailey
Kimberly Cook
Kenny Guerra
Justin Helwick
Rultz Raymond
Detective Swayze's Partner
JoAnn Willette
Debbie Puglisi
Hope Jordan
Carrie Cauldill
Nicole Paris Williams
Barbara Nunn
Kamille McCuin
Cherry Lee Jones
Marlon Perrier
Nelson Jones
Skyler Adams
Jimmy Mickel
Eli T. Peña
Chip Hojan
Euseph Messiah
Sam Hobson
Taina Dominguez
Marie Mendez
Autumn Dial
Tammie Craycraft
Kyle Findley
Cody Simmons
Langley Cornwell
Connie Craycraft
Jack Andrews
Christopher Burns
Megan Rosen
Christy Williams
Julia Vasi
Jodi Sanderholm
Courtney Dietz
Lori Virden
Vanessa French
Cindy Sanderholm
Jack Vincenty
Owen
Burke Brown
Justin Thurber
Mark Knapp
Jake
Aly Ward Azevedo
Anna Wood
Ciarra Siller
Marie Wood
Pamela Gold
Jeanne Smith
David Christian Welborn
Mike Iseman
Travis West
Ron
Braxton Bjerken
Nick Robinson
Jeremy T. Thomas
Scott Wells
Joe Morelli
Detective Bob Anton
Nir Guzinski
Bar Patron
Todd Sheeler
Detective Gerald Swayze
Margaret Press
Self - Author, "A Scream on the Water"
Sarafina King
Martha Brailsford / Muriel (twin sister)
Jason MacDonald
Tom Maimoni
Dorian Santiago
Det. Sgt. Conrad Prosniewski
Lindsay Abernathy
Rosemary
Ashlee Heath
Patti Maimoni
Levi Burdick
Brian Brailsford
Jesse Malinowski
Hooper Goodwin
Casie Bryant
Maggie (Neighbor)
Marty Stonerock
Laurie Cabot (Salem Psychic)
Allen O'Reilly
Harbor Master
Whit Davies
Captain Finn
James Swendsen
Sgt. Sullivan
Lee Buechele
Caretaker
Brandon Wood
Ben (teenager)
David Vann
Character not listed
Brianna Ferris
Sandy Jeffers
Andrew Bellamy
Aaron Skeen
Brody Wellmaker
James Anderson
Kevin Harrison
Carlos Hess
Christina Reynolds
Det. Sgt. Sharon Moore
Lake Roberts
MD Det. Hendley
Jennifer Baskette-Ridings
Angelia Jeffers
David Turner
Sleazy Bank Customer
Suehyla El-Attar Young
Sandy's Neighbor
Angela Ray
Librarian
Marilyn Chung
Student
Shiloh McCully
Character not listed
Kalyn Wood
Cassie Jo Stoddart
Matt Hendren
Matthew Young
Cory Chapman
Tory Adamcik
Tyler Webster
Brian Draper
Andrew Sweeney
Det. John Ganske
Parisa Johnston
Officer Bozek
Denise Arribas
Anna Stoddart
Kirsten Benson
Matt's Mom
Suzanne Salhaney
Aunt Allison
Kristina Arjona
Cousin Kelsey
Briana Starks
Ticket Taker
Kevin Todde Coughlin
Delivery Guy (uncredited)
Todd Brown
Tommy Ray
Bill Osinski
Self - True Crime Author / Former Journalist
Denise Lang
Self - Author, 'The Dark Son'
John Johnston
Self - Former Reporter, A Current Affair
Frank McAdams
Self - True Crime Author, 'Final Affair'
Katherine Ramsland
Self - Forensic Psychologist
Caleb J. Spivak
Harvey Robinson
Fidelus Singleton
Clarence Purdie
Hannah Alline
Sarah Harris
Eileen Bridgeman Biernat
Self - True Crime Author, 'Stalking Mary'