On screen
Cast
57 credited performers
M. William Phelps
Self - Host
John Kelly
Self - Profiler
Emily Stratten
Molly Bish
Victoria Morgan
Cassandra Lee Hailey
Artwork unavailable
Shane Imbert
Police Investigator
Jessica Drew
Party Girl
Kate Ryerson
Cathleen Thomas
Yasmin Horner
Jessica Cain
Artwork unavailable
Amylee Bliss
Samantha Koenig
Nerida Bronwen
Bankteller
John Michael Burdon
Officer Feldis
Samuel Wilson
Israel Keyes
Artwork unavailable
Megan Thomas
Jane
Darren K. Hawkins
The Valley Killer
Artwork unavailable
Donna Brooks
Mary
Artwork unavailable
Melanie Thorpe
Cathy
Melissa Armstrong
Lynda
Artwork unavailable
Joanne Louise Sanders
Whitnei Dubois
Artwork unavailable
Tessa Coulter
Foot Woman
Leanne Mauro
Barbara Breidor
Artwork unavailable
Steven McIntosh
Passerby Maine
Artwork unavailable
Amelia Tranter
Carmen
Artwork unavailable
Liz Harper
Loretta Chaisson
Olivia Stiefel
Nancy
Jason Stojanovski
Drug Guy
Artwork unavailable
Tarisai Vushe
Muggy
Artwork unavailable
Christina Falsone
Carmen Rondriguez
Margaux Harris
Stacey
Heather Ashley Chase
Karen Osmuns
Peter Bertoni
Boyfriend
Amber Gokken
Charlene Smith / Cheri Domingo
Artwork unavailable
Damien Carr
Killer 1
Artwork unavailable
Michelle Collins
Maggi Bish
Artwork unavailable
Peter Djordjevic
Killer
Madeleine Levins
Kelly Disney
Artwork unavailable
Dave W. Phillips
Lead
Karina Banno
Laura Miller
Miranda O'Hare
Heidi Villarreal Fye
Morgan Derera
The I-70 Killer
Rohan Everingham
Male Cop
Emma Mothersdill
Sarah Blessing
Christian L. Scott
Lucretia Gullett
Artwork unavailable
Annick Rickenbach
Patricia Smith
Artwork unavailable
Richard Adams
David Knobling
Artwork unavailable
Stephen Noad
Cop
Jace Pickard
Daniel Lauer
Jamie Vergan
Cop 2 / Hunter Barry
Artwork unavailable
Neda Aslani
Ramona Wilson
Persia Blue
Colleen MacMillen
Yasmin Pegram
Young Colleen MacMillen
Maha Wilson
Gladys Radek
Artwork unavailable
Sonia Carroll
Betty White
Artwork unavailable
Samantha Zinner
Brandy
Val Athanassiou
Joshua Brewer
Danny Elacci
Detective
Natalie Paige
Jane
Artwork unavailable
Elizabeth Wiltshire
Cynthia Ancog