On screen
Cast
76 credited performers
Riki Lindhome
Garfunkel
Kate Micucci
Oates
Mike Phirman
Lenny
Natasha Leggero
Vivian
Michelle Zamora
Puppeteer
Sarah Burns
Cheryl
Busy Philipps
Karen
Rich Fulcher
Dr. Patel
Artemis Pebdani
Janice
Creed Bratton
Kazoo Man
Ben Kingsley
Ben Kingsley
Sugar Lyn Beard
Epiphany
Abby Elliott
Chevrolet
Jerry Lambert
Wesker-Wynn Boss
Karen Maruyama
Susie
Tig Notaro
Pumpernickel Place Producer
John Oates
Dirty D
Russ Walko
Puppeteer
Chris Parnell
Stan
Chris Hardwick
Himself
Steve Agee
Toy Store Cashier
Geoffrey Arend
Todd
Liz Cackowski
Yogurt Woman
Camille Chen
Caroline
Malcolm Barrett
Daniel
Kyle Dunnigan
Josh Duncan
Rob Huebel
Boomer (voice)
Anthony Jeselnik
Thomas
Lance Barber
Drew
Artwork unavailable
Joel Michaely
Marcus
Ashley Johnson
Jane
Mo Mandel
Tom
Nick Thune
Nick
Artwork unavailable
Christopher Smith
Darren
Brent Weinbach
Andy
Artwork unavailable
Allison Buczkowski
Dancer
Ayesha Orange
Dancer
Tia Robinson
Dancer
Noureen DeWulf
Jennifer
Andy Kindler
Michael Andrew Carson
Edward Fordham, Jr.
Bouncer
Steve Little
Dennis
Toby Huss
Tom
Madeline Walter
Shelly
Kevin Pollak
Andrew
Kulap Vilaysack
Laura
Gerry Bednob
Pavel
Rose Abdoo
Magda
Ike Barinholtz
Director
Erin Cahill
Jenny
Eugene Cordero
Fred
Davey Johnson
Gator
Ann Maddox
Colleen
Kumail Nanjiani
Jordan
Jonah Ray Rodrigues
Charlie
Irene Choi
Bethany
Janina Gavankar
Dr. Sharma
Moshe Kasher
Receptionist
Dannah Feinglass Phirman
Meditation Voice
Artwork unavailable
Vladimir Tevlovski
Stunt Coordinator
'Weird Al' Yankovic
Weird Al
Janie Haddad Tompkins
Venue Woman
Ari Graynor
Cornish Amberson
B.K. Cannon
Becky
Beth Dover
Fertility Nurse
Trevor Einhorn
Graham
Kathryn Burns
Dancer
Artwork unavailable
Jillian Schmitz
Dancer
Becca Sweitzer
Dancer
Jimmy Bennett
Braden
Artwork unavailable
Matthew Micucci
George
Joy Regullano
Cafe Waitress
Jason Ritter
Jason
Artwork unavailable
Brandon Ruiter
Caden
T.J. Miller
Matthew
Issac Ryan Brown
Timmy