On screen
Cast
44 credited performers
Paul Scheer
Paul / Various
Rob Huebel
Rob / Various
Aziz Ansari
Aziz / Various
Matt Walsh
Sugarplums Agent / Illusionators Volunteer
H. Jon Benjamin
Jeff Donovan
Brian Posehn
Brian
Mary Lynn Rajskub
Mindy
Bill Hader
Little Kevin
Alison Becker
Character not listed
Artwork unavailable
Andy Blitz
Tony Woliner
Rob Riggle
Barry
Artwork unavailable
Rob Lathan
Tom Cruise Impersonator
Jon Glaser
Ernie Glaser
June Diane Raphael
Casting Director
Tracy Morgan
The Invisible Man (voice)
Fred Armisen
Dr. Marker
Casey Wilson
Young Mom
Linda Cardellini
Melody Richards
Kristen Schaal
Girl in Doritos Commercial
David Cross
Peter Burns
A.D. Miles
CrimeTime Reenactor
Andy Samberg
Jonathan
Patton Oswalt
Let's Go Fan
Atticus Shaffer
Wade Richards (uncredited)
Ghostface Killah
Self
Paul Iacono
Billy Boy
Nick Swardson
Rob's Agent
Jonah Hill
Weenie King Customer
Michael Delaney
NYU Professor
Jay Johnston
Whale Trainer
Nichole Hiltz
Tina
Artwork unavailable
Jackie Clarke
Shelia
Adam Farabee
Reggie
Kristen Ruhlin
Lemonade Girl
Anthony Del Negro
Jack / Lemonade Boy (uncredited)
Will Blagrove
Streetballer
Artwork unavailable
David Foy
Austin Powers Impersonator
Artwork unavailable
Alexandra Gizela
News Reporter
Artwork unavailable
Kenneth Keith Kallenbach
Tom Cruise Impersonator
Susan Lay
Miriam
Artwork unavailable
Angela Muto
Crack Head
Artwork unavailable
Miriam Tolan
Susan
Artwork unavailable
Girstin Bergquist
Waitress / Party Guest (uncredited)
Brandon Johnson
CrimeTime Reenactor