On screen
Cast
125 credited performers
Dr. Michelle Ward
Self - Host / Criminal Psychologist
Ron Mark McClary
Self - Narrator (voice)
Zac Fine
Self - Narrator (voice)
William Otterson
David Haley
John Cerny
Court Judge
Arlo Sarinas
Khia Lee
Kyla Blocker
Marie DePalma
Hanna Edwards
Marie's Mom
Tom Werther
Marie's Father
Nicole Kafka
Deb Perryman
David Davino
Alberto Benitez
Devin Almonte
Elizabeth Reynolds
Stevie Michelle Aycock
Alberto's Ex-Wife
Iva Franks-Singer
Self
Neil Johnson
Self
Amanda Charles
Iva Franks
Charles Parker Newton
Neil Johnson
Krysten Kimmett
Vicki Kuper
Michael Power
Jack Tanner
Sheila Taormina
Self - Olympic Triathlete
Sarah Ann Corkum
Sheila Taormina
Ryan Gaskins
Britt, Sheila's Boyfriend
Michael Urriquia
Nyah Lee
Gloria Chung
Kay Xiong
Donald Chartruce Calliste
Lee Redmond
Lolali Ledlum
Renee Redmond
Apriel Starkweather
Nicole Thornton
Joelle Brunet
Jane Haag
Rob DeFelice
Ron Wright
Robert Wilde
Andrew Bagby
Rhea Sandstrom
Shirley Turner
Sarah DiRenno
Young Sherry
Cory Haynes
Young Chuck
Jo Young
Middle Sherry
Robert Miranda
Middle Chuck
Dawn Ouellette
Older Sherry
Howard Harris
Older Chuck
Heather Schroeder
K.T. Mills
Brian J. Coffey
Andre
Al Moroni
Bob Krueger
Alexandra Dickson
Kathleen Krueger
Jeff Coyne
Tom Humphrey
Katie Jean Mitchell
Young Tracy
Bryan Aldea
Young Shawn
Jessica Bettini
Tracy Lundeen
Ronald Cano
Shawn Moul
Jessica Sierra
Self
Brooke Bergen
Jessica Sierra
Ruth Fonda
Jessica's Meemaw
Raymond Mosser
Jessica's Peepaw
Matt Garafalo
Joseph Sierra, Jessica's Father
Allen Enlow
Daniel Young
Jenna Michno
Jessie Cooper
Jamie Keohane
Debbie Cooper
Rachel Pirard
Young Jessie
Ian Koranek
Nick Hamilton
Kimberly Amato
Sandi Musk
Grant Williams
Andy Lefleur
J.D. Brown
Tom Donato
Vanna Pilgrim
Kristin Donato
Ava Battaglia
Caitlin Donato
Caroline Hearns
Amy Harris
Linda Collins
Kristin's Mother
Jonah Young
George Long
Nancy P. Corbo
Cheryl Vivier
Allie Funk
George's Ex-Wife
Lillith Fallon
Jennifer Paulson
Sean Michael Nugent
Jed Waits
Patti Van Dyke
Judy Phillips
Laura Van Valkenburgh
Trisha Phillips
Randall Klitz
James Cain
Michele Ann Suttile
Trisha's Friend
Madonna
Self (archive footage)
Lorelei Prince
Madonna
Michael Anthony
Basil Stephen's (Bodyguard)
Maggie Pelick
Caresse Henry (Assistant)
Joseph Covino
Robert Hoskins
Gabrielle Ryan
Kaity Sudberry
Duane C. Wallace
Daniel Byrd
Cynthia Latham
Kaity's Stepmom (Bobbi)
Anthony Aroya
Kaity's Dad
Meredyth Kenney
Dawn Krohn Hillyer
Chandra Lynn Albritton
Christen Naujoks
Yolande Ductan
Jamie Tobin (Co-Worker)
Jodi Lynn Smith
Detective Lorrie Bandor
Preston Christopher Lawrence
Richard Ellerbee
Jaqi Furback
Dinah Lynch
Patrick Noth
Stanley Decker
Christy Martin
Self
Kristin Havdoglous
Christy Martin
Hillary Hamilton
Sherry Lusk
Mona Depena
Deborah Roberts
Claire Hampsey
Young Susan Zarriello
Liz Samuel
Susan Zarriello
Gianmarco Soresi
Young David Richards
Trent Lamont Miller
Michael Johnson
Demi Mills
Angell's Daughter
Paul Nielsen
Dave Asmussen
Mischa Ipp
Kathy Haley
Arturo Lazalde
Alex Reid
Christina Daniels
Donna Eskew
David Willis
Glen Johnson
David James Palmer
Robert Vinyard
Maria Mercedes Galuppo
Terri Mendez
Melina Lekkas
Detective Angela Martinez
Samantha Opitz
Elle Richardson
Emily Asaro
Catherine McKinney
Ariella Segal
Jessica Lenahan
Jonathan Iglesias
Simon Gonzales
Kelly Madan
Simon's Girlfriend
Ana Cecilia Stieglitz
Linda Smith
Max Kolby
Linda's Son
Joelene Wolfe
Janet Russell
Samantha Steinmetz
Rachel Wilson
Eric S. Robertson
Darrell Wilson
Abigail Friend
Rachel & Darrell's Daughter
Brandon Kieffer
Ron Ruse
Jamie Josephs
Linda Ricchio
Marcela De Luna
Vicky Woodruff
Dorothy Meyers
Harvette Williams
Mark Anthony
Kevin Gary
Whitney Kimball Long
Amy Johnson
Nate Steinwachs
Dustin Hall
Donna Cutro
Karen Welch
Christopher Syrett
Karen's Son