On screen
Cast
83 credited performers
JoAnna Garcia Swisher
Mia Putney
Jennifer Finnigan
Maddie Putney
Josh Cooke
Ben Coles
Jake Lacy
Casey
Kurt Fuller
Joel Putney
Debra Jo Rupp
Vicky Putney
Artwork unavailable
Hannah Smith
Young Maddie
Jonathan Slavin
Glen
Loanne Bishop
Elaine Dickinson
Artwork unavailable
Emma Hall
Young Mia
J. Michael Silver
Mark
Ron Ostrow
Gage Attendant (voice)
Nick Swisher
Self
Todd Stashwick
Miles
Valorie Hubbard
Bakery Manager
Artwork unavailable
Justin Dean Jones
Cameron
Dennis Cockrum
Phil
Tiya Sircar
Reena
Jerrika Hinton
Saleswoman
Jeff Austin
Donny
Harrison White
Carl
Patrick O'Connor
Paul
Sean Moran
Richie
Adam Shapiro
Steve
Aaron Farb
Tall Hat Guy
Edward James Gage
Tom
Nikita Ager
Wendy
Ben Tolpin
Darth Waiter (voice)
Artwork unavailable
Frank Arend
Man on TV
Anabelle D. Munro
Woman on TV
Valerie Mahaffey
Ariel
Reba McEntire
Lorraine Ashley
Joanna Canton
Amy
Jennifer DeMille
Tami
Rich Ceraulo Ko
Rory
Lyn Alicia Henderson
Lucy
Artwork unavailable
Jared Butler
Elevator V.O. (voice)
Joe Dietl
Mailman No.
Lamont Thompson
Mailman
Tommy Dewey
Ron
Artwork unavailable
Lanre Idewu
Waiter
Artwork unavailable
Michael Feinstein
Self
Martin Spanjers
Hunter
John O'Brien
Florist
DeeDee Rescher
Sophia
Artwork unavailable
Sean Abbott
Quizmaster
Artwork unavailable
Brittany Alexis Phillips
Hooker
Katherine Von Till
Cynthia
Brian Treitler
Guy
Brady Matthews
Jake the Bartender
Artwork unavailable
Jonathan Margolis
Pizza Guy
Tory N. Thompson
Pizza Guy
Michael Paul Gibben
Bar Regular
Artwork unavailable
Wolfgang Track
Bar Regular
Michael Patrick McGill
Cop
Artwork unavailable
Melissa Cook
Waitress
Samaire Armstrong
Jessica
Peter MacKenzie
Neil
Leslie Grossman
Francine
Rachel Eggleston
Katie
Artwork unavailable
Symba
Hostess
Larry King
Self
Derek Hough
Philip
Lauren Benz Phillips
Other Bride
Indira G. Wilson
Bridal Shop Manager
John Brantley Cole
Flower Shop Manager
Artwork unavailable
Laurie Landry
Bridal Shop Employee
Jake Morgan
Wedding Guest
Terry Rhoads
Gerard
Bob Morrisey
Mr. Straf
Yolanda Snowball
Natalie
Susan Boyajian
Patrice
Doug Simpson
Lawyer
Jeffrey Muller
Lawyer
Anthony Holiday
Lawyer
Edward Herrmann
Judge
Tara Karsian
Arletta
Candace Kita
Dr. Rettig
Artwork unavailable
Elizabeth Tobias
Sylvia
Treisa Gary
Woman In Line
Jean Paul San Pedro
Guy In Line
Gregor Manns
Dennis Killian
Jonathan Spencer
Guy in Line No.