On screen
Cast
26 credited performers
Ellison Barber
Self - Host
Misty Marris
Self - Trial Attorney & Legal Analyst
Philip C. Hamilton
Self - Criminal Defense Attorney
Laura Jarrett
Self - NBC News Senior Legal Correspondent
Kristen Gibbons Feden
Self - Trial Attorney & Legal Analyst
Tracy Walder
Self - Former CIA Officer & FBI Special Agent
Gabby Petito
Self (archive footage) (uncredited)
Brian Laundrie
Self (archive footage) (uncredited)
Christine Marie
Self
Roberta Laundrie
Self (archive footage) (uncredited)
Chris Laundrie
Self (archive footage) (uncredited)
Maddie Misleh
Self - Spencer Tepe's Sister
Rob Misleh
Self - Spencer Tepe's Brother-In-Law
Elaine Bryant
Self - Columbus Police Department (archive footage)
Evy Poumpouras
Self - NBC News Law Enforcement Analyst
Nichole Schmidt
Self - Gabby Petito's mother
Dan Slepian
Self - Senior Investigative Producer, Dateline
Dean O’Kelley
Self - Lead Detective (archive footage)
Colleen Beyer
Self - Sharon's Daughter (archive footage)
Kathy Thomas
Self - Randolph's First Wife (archive footage)
Steve Thomas
Self - Randolph's Former Associate (archive footage)
Rosalie Allred
Self - Beckie's Aunt (archive footage)
Eric Tarantino
Self - Randolph's Former Associate (archive footage)
Martha DeGraw
Self - Beckie's Mother (archive footage)
Gayna Allmon
Self - Randolph's Fourth Wife (archive footage)
Carolyn Austin
Self - Frances' Sister (archive footage)