On screen
Cast
93 credited performers
Ella Beatty
Lizzie Borden
Vicky Krieps
Bridget Sullivan
Sarah Paulson
Aileen Wuornos
Charlie Hunnam
Andrew Borden
Rebecca Hall
Abby Borden
Billie Lourd
Emma Borden
Jessica Barden
Nance O'Neil
Oliver Spenceman
Stephen
Joey Pollari
John Morse
Scarlett DeMeo
Sarah Anthony Borden
Gracjela Kicaj
Ilona
Caterina Grosoli
Doryotta
Anastasia Zarbo
Katarina
Ember Ambrose
8-Year-Old Emma
Aimee McGuire
Margaret
Linda Reiter
Bertha Manchester
Fred Maske
Postmaster
Anthony DeCarlo
Policeman
Chad Coe
Deputy Francis Wixon
Joseph Schwartz
Officer George Allen
Michael Sean Tighe
Pharmacist
Herbert Russell
Coroner
Chris O'Shea
Heath Westcott
Brian Knoebel
Son
Sandra Kate Burck
Daughter
Lidia Vitale
Servant
Therese McLaughlin
Widow
Michael McCusker
Bard Wainwright
Gabriel Sousa
Tiago
Aaron Hendry
Oberon
Sara Mennella
Hungarian Mother
Oskar Winiarski
Hungarian Father
Brian Tichnell
Playgoer
Jim Cody Williams
Fishmonger
David St. James
Doctor
Dario Masciello
Magistrate
Samuel Dunning
Policeman
Antonio Araujo
Vendor
Krosby João Roza
Gardener
Mateo Bourdieu
Gardener
Cindy Michelle
Neighbor
Zachary Mooren
Atelier
Ruth Fox
Another Maggie
Elise Krieps
Young Elizabetta
Gabriele Santolin
Footman
Simon Ticci
Footman
Sofia Iacuitto
Eldest Daughter
Sofia Carnevale
2nd Eldest Daughter
Favia Leone
Middle Daughter
Lara Bucci
2nd Youngest Daughter
Siria Sant
Youngest Daughter
Lauri Hendler
Mrs. Enid Wheatley
Jack Lancaster
Brother Borden
Elizabeth Scopel
Callie
Stewart Skelton
Minister
Madylin Sweeten
Trixie
Patricia Westerfield
Mrs. Seward
John Venable
Monsignor
Joshua Close
Officer Patrick Doherty
Ezra Buzzington
Detective Michael Mullaly
Alan Heitz
Detective John Devine
Jessica Lee
Shelby
Bernadette Guckin
Carolyn
Tom Virtue
Doctor
Jeanine Anderson
Neighbor
John Ales
Hosea Knowlton
Kristy Munden
Constance Meade
Greg Barnett
AP William Moody
Jordan Hendricks
Assistant District Attorney
Jay Alan Christianson
Jury Foreman
Michael O'Connell
Defense Attorney
Tom Fitzpatrick
Judge
Daniel Abraham Stevens
Bailiff
Matthew Siegan
Reporter
Dorian Martin
Reporter
Doug Cox
Juror #4
Steven Lee Allen
Juror #6
Michael X. Sommers
Juror #8
Ari Graynor
Michelle Gillen
Hugo Armstrong
Harlan
Joanna Leeds
Tricia Jenkins
Trilby Glover
Thandie Wilcox
Robbie Kaller
Steven Glazer
Jim O'Brien
Judge Uriel Blount
A.J. Tannen
Judge Thomas Saway
Abby Wathen
Dawn Botkins
Gabrielle Sanalitro
Lead Juror
Francesca D'Urso
Arthella
Eleonora Haerens
Angela
Troy Blendell
Coroner
Jacopo Olmo Antinori
Western Union Man
Luca Pusceddu
Partygoer
Anthony J. Tremé
Muckraker