On screen
Cast
24 credited performers
Mikey Day
Self - Host
Andrew Fuller
Self - Contestant
Jonny Manganello
Self - Contestant
Rachel Bloom
Self - Guest Judge
Wayne Brady
Self - Guest Judge
Sebastian Maniscalco
Self - Guest Judge
Hannah Berner
Self - Guest Judge
Tiffany Haddish
Self - Guest Judge
Devon Walker
Self - Guest Judge
James Austin Johnson
Self - Guest Judge
Chris Witaske
Self - Guest Judge
Sasheer Zamata
Self - Guest Judge
Terry Crews
Self - Guest Judge
Punkie Johnson
Self - Guest Judge
Randall Park
Self - Guest Judge
Kel Mitchell
Self - Guest Judge
Dustin Milligan
Self - Guest Judge
Wendi McLendon-Covey
Self - Guest Judge
Kristen Bell
Self - Guest Judge
Pierson Fodé
Self - Guest Judge
Lamorne Morris
Self - Guest Judge
Michael Urie
Self - Guest Judge
Andrew Bachelor
Self - Guest Judge
Lacey Chabert
Self - Guest Judge