On screen
Cast
100 credited performers
Bret McKenzie
Bret McKenzie
Jemaine Clement
Jemaine Clement
Rhys Darby
Murray Hewitt
Kristen Schaal
Mel
Arj Barker
Dave
Frank Wood
Greg
Eugene Mirman
Eugene
David Costabile
Doug
Sutton Foster
Coco
Lenny Venito
John
Brian Sergent
New Zealand Prime Minister Brian
Rachel Blanchard
Sally
Aida Lembo
Synchronized Swimmer
Adrian Martinez
Hotelier
José Ramón Rosario
Hansom Cab Driver
Kelly Taffe
Police Officer
Victor Williams
Police Officer West
Lucy Lawless
Paula
Alan Dale
Australian Ambassador
Greg Proops
Martin Clark
Mary Lynn Rajskub
Art Garfunkel Fanatic
Sarah Wynter
Keitha
Kristen Wiig
Brahbrah
Jim Gaffigan
Jim
Jonno Roberts
Stage Murray
Will Forte
Ben
Andrea Rosen
Caitlin Goodman
Dena Kaplan
Keli
Sarah Burns
Summer
June Diane Raphael
Felicia
Luther Creek
Mickey
Adam Garcia
Obnoxious Australian
John Hodgman
David Armstrong
Patton Oswalt
Elton John Impersonator
Kevin Allison
Customer
Demetri Martin
Demetri
Eliza Coupe
Lisa
Art Garfunkel
Self
Aziz Ansari
Sinjay
Murray Bartlett
Mark
Eddie Pepitone
Eddie
Judah Friedlander
Isabella
Seymour Cassel
Johnny Boy
John Turturro
Credits Cop
Dan Bakkedahl
Waiter
Todd Barry
Todd
Diana Bologna
John's Date
Marilyn Torres
Jemaine's Date
Ramsey Faragallah
John
Jon Budinoff
Mexican Boy
Joan Hess
Jessica
Sylvia Kauders
Lady on Bus
Taika Waititi
Gypsy Kings Fan
Megan Neuringer
Lisa's Friend
Betsy Morgan
Blonde Girl
Emily Swallow
Becky
Kate Pierson
Club Owner
Michelle Santagate
Swim Team Member
Daryl Hall
World Music Jam Host
Heather Lawless
Rain
Inca Son
Themselves
Lisa Valenzuela
Herself
Charles Rosenay
Elton John Impersonator #2
Mark A. Langston
Bartender
Andrew Secunda
Glenn
Clayton Dean Smith
Promoter
Anjali Bhimani
Potential Client #2
Mary Catherine Garrison
Character not listed
Karen Gertsman
Character not listed
Michael Potts
Nigel Saladu
Nancy Ticotin
Character not listed
Ray Wineteer
Record Executive
Kina Bermudez
Lisa's Best Friend
Edward Furs
Character not listed
Jamie Jackson
Australian
Benjamin Howes
Australian
Jack A. O'Connell
Uncle
Ray Bokhour
Character not listed
Mao Zhao
Character not listed
Michael Heintzman
Character not listed
Allie Woods Jr.
Character not listed
Louis Ortiz
Barack Obama
Susan Blommaert
Character not listed
Jacob Knoll
Character not listed
Jo Sung
Korean Karaoke Singer
Leigh Ann Larkin
Hot Woman
Madison McKinley
Gel Girl
Halley Feiffer
Savannah
James Arden
Sven
Anthony Fazio
Stage Eugene
Richard DeDomenico
Character not listed
Nancy Opel
Aunt
Richard Wilkinson
Reuben
James Smith
Maxwell
Feng Lui
Mr. Lee
Gregory Ippolito
Kid A
Antonio Edwards Suarez
Character not listed
Wai Ching Ho
Mrs. Lee
Michael Chen
Kid B
Andrea Weston
American Woman