On screen
Cast
94 credited performers
Mark Feuerstein
Jake Silver
Ashley Williams
Dylan Messinger
Constance Zimmer
Penny Barnes Barrington
Jere Burns
Frank Alfano
Matt Letscher
Gavin Stone
Suzanne Pleshette
Claire Arnold
Stephon Fuller
Robbie
Tiffani Thiessen
Victoria Hill
Tessie Santiago
Lucia Rojas-Klein
Brooke Dillman
Sister Brenda Trogman
Jillian Warry Barberie
Joni
Bob Clendenin
Carl
Tracy Vilar
Stacey
Fran Drescher
Roberta Diaz
Tom Poston
Lenny
Hal Holbrook
Jim Templeton
Edward James Gage
Tiny
Joanna Cassidy
Gavin's Mother
Andrea Savage
Cindy
Amy Farrington
Erika
Jolie Jenkins
Cheryl
Viola Kates Stimpson
Old Woman
Jordan Feldman
Guy
Butch Klein
Dale the Delivery Guy
John Balma
Maitre d'
Karen Bankhead
Nurse Becker
Kenneth Mars
Marty
Bess Armstrong
Louise Messinger
Lydia Blanco Garza
Nurse Debbie
Christopher Gehrman
Water Guy
Loren Lester
Group Leader
Madison Mason
Soldier
Lori Alan
Loretta
Doug Ballard
Walter
Billy Pollina
Cheech
Rafer Weigel
Adam
Nick Offerman
Officer
Joe Rogan
Self
J. Michael Flynn
Paolo
Sierra Abel
Jamie
Jackie Geary
Angela
Bob Morrisey
Bert
Carrie Preston
Kiera
Paul Caroul
Painter Brother
Tina D'Marco
Conchita-the parrot
Jeremy Forte
Howard
Ted Allen
Self
Kyan Douglas
Self
Thom Filicia
Self
Brian Howe
Steve
Carson Kressley
Self
Jai Rodriguez
Self
T.J. Thyne
Trevor
Jennifer Elise Cox
Character not listed
Jeff D'Agostino
Ty
Niyi Oni
Jay
Mary Lynn Rajskub
Hollis
Seth Altschull
Donald
Tony Ervolina
Man
Wallace Langham
Ken
Myrna Niles
Woman
Burgess Jenkins
Jimmy
Brian Palermo
Trip
Sarah Rafferty
Lila
Matthew Glave
Phil
John Aylward
Mr. Fowler
Carrie Fisher
Judy Silver
Steve Paymer
Lloyd
Terry Rhoads
Howie
Stephen Rockwell
Warren
Dina Sherman
Sandra
Billy West
Billy
Chad Gabriel
Store Employee
Deborah Levin
Frances
Michael Medico
Bartender
Brett Buford
Alfred
Suzy Nakamura
Carol
Todd Stashwick
Nick
Sam Pancake
Jordy
Curtis Armstrong
Jeweler
Paul Tigue
Father Bowman
Kevin Brief
Troy
Valerie Mahaffey
Sara
Paul Anthony Reynolds
Mike
Will Collyer
Steve
Joey Hardy Gray
Brian
Shira Scott Astrof
Sara
Kristina Lear
Seba
Shashawnee Hall
Reverend Earl
George Wyner
Larry
Marc Alaimo
Violinist
Jordan Baker
Kayla
Seemah Wilder
Maude
Anne Meara
Evelyn