On screen
Cast
114 credited performers
Annaleigh Ashford
Melissa Reed
Dennis Quaid
Keith Jesperson aka 'Happy Face Killer'
James Wolk
Ben Reed
Tamera Tomakili
Ivy Campbell
Khiyla Aynne
Hazel Reed
Benjamin Mackey
Max Reed
Connor Paton
Tyler
David Harewood
Dr. Greg
Momona Tamada
Eva
Michael O'Neill
D.A. Craig Calloway
River Codack
Josh
Zara Nikou Sichani
Victoria
Damon Gupton
Elijah
Charles Zuckermann
C.O. Bassett
Marci T. House
Joyce
Beverley Elliott
Denise's Friend
Nola Augustson
Denise
Ava Telek
Summer
Philip Granger
Chave
Kathleen Duborg
June
Jennifer Spence
Renee
Kate Sullivan
Teen Melissa
Kiefer O'Reilly
Teen Shane
Zabryna Guevara
Gabriela
Patrick Gilmore
Cody O'Neill
Eric Keenleyside
Carl O'Neill
Teach Grant
Ashton McBride
Jason Beaudoin
Frankie
Jenn Lyon
Gillian
Harrison Xu
Stewart
Cammie Clarke
Young Becky
Chanelle Peloso
Adele
Ramona Kim
Ms. Walters
Shayn Walker
Texas Prison Guard #1
Debbie Podowski
Jackie
Philip Ettinger
Shane
Paul McGillion
William
Toby Hargrave
Bob
Jonathan Whitesell
Nico
Sandy Sidhu
Dr. Wendy Chin
Hilary McCormack
Heather
Lisa Solberg
Reporter #1
Christopher Pearce
Reporter #2
Jenna Romanin
Tabitha
Jillian Fargey
Kathy Weaver
Gregory Greenwood
Joseph
Melissa G. Moore
Segment Producer
Carson Bokenfohr
Clerk
Fabian Gujral
John the Lawyer
Doris Maria Bregolisse
Reporter
Richard Elias Anderson
Mail Carrier
Rina Pellerin
Female Bartender
Vale Cooper
Young Missy
Johnny Scozzafava
Young Shane
Paul Moniz de Sa
Gary
Derek Kwan
Spokane Officer #1
Ben Christensen
Spokane Officer #2
Leah Jacksties
Extra Heather
Maria Ameerali
Owner
Rebecca Husain
Tina
Arvin Shah
General Store Clerk
Lola Rose Mackay
Bully Girl #1
Kristina Lao
Roxanne
Elizabeth Weinstein
Lydia Morgan
Ted Cole
Eddie
Amanda May
Caryn
Jasmine Lukuku
Frances
Eugene Mundowa
Rodrigo
Liz Wallace
Hannah
Mark Kandborg
Harrold Griffin
Gardiner Millar
Pastor Baker
Cecil MacRae
Young Ash
Ali Tarhouni
Chef Emilio
Tim Dixon
Judge
Darryl Scheelar
Prosecutor
Tyson Bellusci
Solitary Guard
Kyle Rideout
Brendan
Belinda Williams
Aunt Claire
Lynnette Kissoon
Receptionist
Billy Wickman
Manny
Kapila Rego
Lark
Aaron Paul Stewart
Thrift Store Employee
Brandon McEwan
Teen Brendan
Elias Leacock
Young Elijah
Wonser De-Gbon
Flo Carter
Jennie George
Diane
Patricia Drake
Alice
Patsy Thompson
Nico's Mother
Nevin Burkholder
New Store Clerk
Anthony Bailey
Texan Prison Guard #2
James Coupland
Texas Prison Guard #3
Sharmaine Yeoh
DNA Lab Tech
John Tench
Ziggy
Sandy Robson
Ennis / Driver
Stephanie Cho
Junior Associate
Jorden Birch
Bailiff
Michael St. John Smith
Judge Wilkins
Micah Steinke
OSP Guard
Otto Szabo
Black-Eyed Inmate
Ziah Diango
Little Girl
Jamall Johnson
Inmate #1
Melissah Charboneau
Bartender
Lisbeth Rosana
Female Bar Patron
Jordan Dannish
Lawyer (uncredited)
Peter Cambor
Young Carl O'Neill
Nathan Parrott
Teen Keith
Stew McLean
Les (Keith's Father)
Emmet Matheson
Smitty
Trey Helten
Prisoner #1
Karen Khunkhun
Reporter
Gavin Langelo
OSP Prison Guard
Emmanuel Amadeo Badal
Basketball Prisoner
Shaw Madson
Sheriff Deputy
Brittany Clough
Bartender