On screen
Cast
40 credited performers
Kathryn Hahn
Agnes O'Connor / Agatha Harkness
Joe Locke
Teen
Sasheer Zamata
Jennifer Kale
Ali Ahn
Alice Wu-Gulliver
Debra Jo Rupp
Mrs. Hart
Patti LuPone
Lilia Calderu
Aubrey Plaza
Rio Vidal
David Payton
Herb
Chau Naumova
Salem Seven / Coyote
Bethany Curry
Salem Seven / Crow
Athena Perample
Salem Seven / Fox
Alicia Vela-Bailey
Salem Seven / Owl
Britta Grant
Salem Seven / Rat
Marina Mazepa
Salem Seven / Snake
Okwui Okpokwasili
Salem Seven / Vertigo
David Lengel
Jones
Asif Ali
Norm
Chloe Camp
Young Lilia
Laura Boccaletti
Lilia's Maestra
Maria Dizzia
Rebecca Kaplan
Paul Adelstein
Jeff Kaplan
Emma Caulfield
Dottie
Amos Glick
Dennis the Mailman
Artwork unavailable
Elaine Valdes
Customer #1
Artwork unavailable
Paria Akbarshahi
Customer #2
Elizabeth Anweis
Lorna Wu
Scott Butler
The Doctor
Jade Quon
The Demon
Kate Forbes
Evanora Harkness
Miles Gutierrez-Riley
Eddie
Evan Peters
Ralph Bohner
Artwork unavailable
James Bostick
EMT
Erica Frene
Event Planner
Artwork unavailable
Alexandria Shuval-Weiner
Rabbi Levin
Abel Lysenko
Nicholas Scratch
Hannah Lowther
Forest Witch
Tetra Lloyd
Singing Forest Witch
Henriette Zoutomou
Village Witch
Holly Bonney
Tavern Witch
Kim Bass
Young Witch