On screen
Cast
104 credited performers
Holmes
Kelly Mallet
Sam Straley
Lloyd 'Shrub' Mallet
Seann William Scott
Joseph 'Father Joe' Binghoffer
Justin Linville
Mickey St. Jean
Krystal Smith
Mandy 'Big Mandy' Matthews
Aya Cash
Cheryl Peterson
Taylor Ortega
Nadine Garcia-Parney
Karen Huie
June
William Tokarsky
Len
Erin Bowles
Beth
Jaime Pressly
Barb Flatch
Kyle Selig
Dylan
Sheila M. O'Rear
Leotha
Banks Repeta
Levi
Jason MacDonald
Bobby
Weldon Sipe
Mr. Piswall
Heather Rule
Jessie
James 'Jimbo' Tibbetts
Fargas
Taylor Grace Boughton
Map Buying Kid
Parker E. Chick
Young Kelly
Ed Wagenseller
Sheriff's Deputy
Troy Hammond
Blind Billy
Shane Callahan
Dave
Alisa Harris
Sheriff
Desmin Borges
Jimmy
Peggy Sheffield
Linda
Josh Warren
Robot Scarecrow
Austin Alexander
Matt
Timmy Sherrill
Beth's Dad
Gabriella Cila
Angry Girl #1
Taylor McCall Moore
Angry Girl #2
Jason Battle
Angry Guy
Lee Armstrong
S. Perkins / D. Perkins
Bayne Gibby
Laura
Zele Avradopoulos
Art Teacher
Gillie Jones
Shelly
Murray Hill
Murray
Jack B. Young
Young Dylan
Rebekah Yang
Waiter
Ginny MacColl
Kelly's Grandma
Clayton Frank
Bus Boy
Martina Litty
Nadine's Friend
Amanda Nicholas
Cynthia
Sean Michael Weber
Young Guy
Mary Lou Faircloth
Bessie
Louise Quince Harrison
Luanne
Chad Michael Baird
Flatch Town Local
Kurt Roberson
Guy
Craig Newkirk
Chris Warner
Joan Reilly
Motorist
Kent West
Townsperson #2
Jana Allen
Parishioner
Jenique Bennett
Nurse
Omer Mughal
Jordan
Rakesh Gosain
Maintenance Man
Robert Walker Branchaud
Daniel
Trent Mayo
Rodney
Jason McDonald
Bobby
Aldan Karanovich
Aldous
Gabe Wood
Townsperson #1
Affion Crockett
Julius
Kate Kneeland
Maureen
Daniel Johnson
Coworker
D.W. Moffett
Doug
Derek Evans
Tim
Lulu Picart
Jen
Martin Herlihy
Chris Jordan
Indy Sullivan Groudis
Boy
Townsend Fallica
Young Boy
Henry Freshwater
Ashlynn #1
Helen Rose Smith
Ashlynn #2
Kurt Hockenberry
Fireman
Artemis Pebdani
Lola
Ginger Curl
Marlene
Stella Threatt
Baby Ashlynn #1
Ellie Threatt
Baby Ashlynn #2
Ron Blake
Featured Parade Bass Drummer (uncredited)
Shane Burnett
Flatchian (uncredited)
Logan Newkirk
Featured Parade Member (uncredited)
Andrew Brooks
Ice Cream Man (uncredited)
Donick Cary
Chris Warner
William G. Tomek
Pedestrian (uncredited)
Michael Sokol
Charlie
Sunny Williams
Candace
Rebekah Kostyal
Laughing Woman #1
Mennelly
Laughing Woman #2
Keeley Kollmann
Realtor (uncredited)
Atkins Estimond
Psychic
Mitch Eakins
Rick "The Hot Hermit"
Pat Dortch
Maynard
Heather Magee
Ohio Influencer
Adam Ray
Bert
Ricky Wayne
Stan
Brooke Jaye Taylor
Dr. Newton
Montrel Miller
Emcee
Carole Kaboya
Realtor
Jordan Aaron Ford
Clerk
Stephen Branson
Flatchian (uncredited)
Derrick Etienne Jr.
Derrick Etienne
Whit Blanchard
Lloyd Mallet Esq.
Ava Gail Prince
Flatch Kid
Nathan Penrose
Toy Drive Attendee (uncredited)
Derek Richardson
Lloyd Bush
Cate Freedman
Renee