On screen
Cast
39 credited performers
Penn Badgley
Joel Larsen
Tom Everett Scott
Joel
Angela Goethals
Cheryl Larsen
Josh Wise
Pat Brody
Natasha Melnick
Isabelle Meyers
Michael Milhoan
Bill Larsen
Gigi Rice
Karen Larsen
Melinda Sward
Character not listed
Julius Carry
Character not listed
Thomas F. Wilson
Character not listed
Jason Kravits
Character not listed
Christopher Hatfield
Joel (voice, uncredited)
Ana Ortiz
Character not listed
Sam Horrigan
Character not listed
Erin Mackey
Character not listed
Robert Torti
Character not listed
Bobby Edner
Character not listed
Jennifer Coolidge
Gwen Brody
Yvette Nicole Brown
Character not listed
Erica Hubbard
Character not listed
Ken Marino
Character not listed
Maury Sterling
Character not listed
Ben Stein
Character not listed
Barry Livingston
Character not listed
Erik von Detten
Character not listed
Patrick Breen
Character not listed
Davida Williams
Suzie
Bryan Fisher
Mike Carusso/Indiana Jones
Stephen Tobolowsky
Character not listed
Mehcad Brooks
Character not listed
Mike Erwin
Character not listed
Greg Cromer
Character not listed
Aaron Himelstein
Character not listed
Nicholas D'Agosto
Character not listed
Spencer Garrett
Character not listed
Taran Killam
Character not listed
Artwork unavailable
David Vincent
Character not listed
Derek Lee Nixon
Character not listed
Josh Henderson
Jake