On screen
Cast
36 credited performers
Lindsay Lohan
Avery
Ian Harding
Logan
Kristin Chenoweth
Erica
Jon Rudnitsky
Cameron
Katie Baker
Cassie
Jake Brennan
Callum
Dan Bucatinsky
Leonard
Tim Meadows
Stan
Judy Reyes
Margaret
Ash Santos
Sophie
Henry Czerny
Mitchell
Bobbie Eakes
Cheryl
Melinda Tanner
Ida
Mim Drew
Susan
Chris Parnell
Veterinarian
Kurt Yue
Priest
Artwork unavailable
Nathan Alexander Tutterrow
Altar Boy
Jade Fernandez
Holly
Brian Unger
Paul
Artwork unavailable
Kimberly Donyale
Middle Aged Woman
Sunny Williams
Church Lady
Artwork unavailable
Leah Selene
Nativity Kid
Artwork unavailable
Warren Abercrombie
Construction Man
Artwork unavailable
Christopher Deforest
Choir Member
Artwork unavailable
Roy Jenkins
Choir Member
Artwork unavailable
Corrie Henson
Choir Member
Artwork unavailable
Janeen Michael
Choir Member
Jasper Randall
Choir Member
Artwork unavailable
Kathy J. Carey
Choir Member
Artwork unavailable
Mark Blankenship
Choir Member
Artwork unavailable
Rachael Chao
Choir Member
Artwork unavailable
Rita Shealy
Choir Member
Artwork unavailable
Sonya Da Silva
Choir Member
Artwork unavailable
Steve Adam Henson
Choir Member
Artwork unavailable
Tim Ellis
Choir Member
Artwork unavailable
Wendy Young McKinnon
Choir Member